In the kitchen, he comes every time. Rattle the treat bag and he's there before you finish saying his name.
In the yard with a lizard? At the beach? Near another dog? You might as well be invisible.
You're not alone, and your dog isn't spiteful. A come that only works when nothing else is going on isn't finished yet. Here's why it breaks down, and how to build one that holds up.
Why Your Dog Ignores You Outside
He learned it in the kitchen
Dogs don't automatically carry a skill from one place to another. Coming in a quiet kitchen and coming away from a squirrel are two very different jobs. Understanding a behavior and reliably performing it are two different things. (The Four Stages of Training)
Coming to you ends the fun
If "come" always means the leash goes on, playtime ends, or he gets put in the crate, he figures that out fast. Why would he hurry?
You said it ten times
"Come. Come. COME. Buddy, come!" Every time you repeat it and nothing happens, he learns that the first nine don't count.
Ignoring you worked
If he's been able to ignore "come" and keep sniffing, chasing or playing, he's been practicing not coming. Dogs do what you teach or what you allow.
The distraction is worth more than you are
A squirrel is exciting. A piece of dry kibble is not. If you want to win, you need to be worth coming to.
How to Build a Come That Works
1. Make coming the best thing that ever happens
When he gets to you, pay him well. Great food, real praise, a game. Make it worth leaving whatever he was doing.
2. Call him once
Say it one time, clearly, in a happy voice. If he doesn't come, don't repeat it. Go get him, calmly, or use the leash to help him get it right. Then make it easier next time.
3. Call him during play, then let him go back
During play or a sniff, call him, reward him, and then release him to go back to what he was doing. This teaches your dog that listening does not end the fun.
4. Don't call him for things he hates
If you need to give a bath, trim nails, or end a great time at the park, go get him instead. Save "come" for good things.
5. Use it all day
Call him when you need him to come to you. Call him in from the yard. On walks, call him if he's ahead or sniffing too long. No drills. Just real life. (Easy Ways to Train All Day)
6. Climb the ladder slowly
Gradually practice around greater distractions. Inside first. Then the yard. Then on leash outside. Then around real distractions. If he fails, you went too far, too fast. Go back a rung.
The recall ladder: climb one rung at a time
Call, reward big, let him go back to what he was doing.
Family moving around, a toy on the floor.
More smells, more to look at. Keep it easy to win.
Call when he is sniffing; a leash means he cannot practice ignoring you.
Only when every rung below is easy.
Source: Maggie Marshall's own training guidance ("Gradually practice around greater distractions").
7. Keep a leash on until it's reliable
Until he comes every time, don't give him the chance to practice ignoring you. A leash, or a long leash in open spaces, means you can always follow through. Follow through on commands your dog understands.
8. Keep practice short
You don't need long sessions. In one study of dogs learning a new task, short, single sessions led to better learning than three sessions back to back. Five minutes here and there, every day, beats an hour on Saturday.
Keep Him Safe While You Work on It
- Don't let him off leash in unfenced areas until his come is reliable around real distractions. One missed recall near a road is one too many.
- Dog parks and off-leash areas are places where dogs may work things out themselves. If he doesn't come when called, he isn't ready for them.
- Watch the Florida heat. Practice in the cooler parts of the day.
The Payoff
There is nothing quite like calling your dog and watching him run to you joyfully. That's what we're building. And once you have it, you can give him more freedom, because you can trust him.
Related Reading
- Why Your Dog Pulls on the Leash Outside but Walks Fine at Home
- Why a Dog That Knows "Sit" Still Struggles With Everyday Manners
- How to Help Your Dog Settle Down When Life Gets Busy
- Dog Training for Busy West Palm Beach Owners: Making Progress Between Sessions
Want a Come That Works?
"Come when called that works" is one of the six skills in The Six Essentials, and it's a common Single Session topic, too. We practice in your home and your yard, then build up from there. I offer private in-home dog training anywhere in Palm Beach County, including West Palm Beach, with no travel fees.
Book your free call or call 561-884-2403.
When we learn, our dogs will listen.
Sources
- Demant H, Ladewig J, Balsby TJS, Dabelsteen T. "The effect of frequency and duration of training sessions on acquisition and long-term memory in dogs." Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 2011;133(3-4):228-234. doi:10.1016/j.applanim.2011.05.010 (summary, University of Copenhagen)
- Recall, follow-through and distraction guidance: Maggie Marshall, The Four Stages of Training and Easy Ways to Train All Day.
Related topics: dog recall training | dog won't come when called | teach a dog to come | reliable recall around distractions | dog training West Palm Beach