Is Your Dog Reactive, or Just Untrained?

"My dog is reactive." I hear it all the time, usually from a worried owner whose dog barks, pulls and lunges when another dog walks by.

Here's the truth: most dogs that owners describe as reactive aren't truly reactive. They're untrained. And that's good news, because training is something we can fix.

What People Usually Mean by "Reactive"

When people say "reactive," they usually mean a big, loud reaction to something specific: another dog, a person, a bike, the mailman. Barking, pulling, lunging, spinning at the end of the leash. It's embarrassing, and it makes walks miserable.

But a big reaction doesn't tell us why it's happening. And the why is what matters.

Why Labels Don't Help

I've said this for years: it is important to refrain from labeling a dog. Labels are misleading and don't give us useful information. Behaviors come and go, and they're the dog's way of communicating. (Commonly Misunderstood Behaviors and Terms)

Once a dog is labeled "reactive," people start treating the label instead of teaching the dog. They avoid, they apologize, they buy gadgets. What they don't do is teach him what to do instead.

Signs Your Dog Might Just Be Untrained

Ask yourself honestly:

  • Does he pull on the leash everywhere, not just near other dogs?
  • Does he ignore his name as soon as something interesting shows up?
  • Can he sit and wait at the front door, or does he blast through it?
  • Does he get everything for free at home: food, attention, the couch, the door?
  • Has anyone ever practiced calm walking with him around other dogs, a little at a time?

If you answered yes, yes, no, yes, no, your dog probably isn't "reactive." He just doesn't know the rules yet. Dogs do what you teach or what you allow. If nobody has taught him what to do when a dog walks by, he'll make it up, loudly.

Untrained, or something more?

Probably just untrainedWorth a closer look
Pulls on the leash everywhere, not just near dogsShaking, hiding or trying to get away
Ignores his name when something interesting appearsRefuses food he would normally love
Blasts through the front doorA reaction that appeared suddenly in a dog who used to be fine (see your vet first)
Gets everything for free at homeSigns of pain: limping, stiffness, sensitivity to touch

Sources: Maggie Marshall's own guidance; pain and behavior: Mills et al., Animals, 2020 (see Sources below).

When It May Be More Than Training

Some dogs really are worried. Watch for:

  • Shaking, hiding, or trying to get away
  • Refusing food he'd normally love
  • A reaction that appeared suddenly in a dog who used to be fine. Pain and illness change behavior, so see your vet first. Researchers estimate that around a third of dogs referred for behavior problems have some painful condition.

A dog cannot behave well if he doesn't feel safe, or if his basic needs aren't met. If this sounds like your dog, don't push him closer to prove a point. Give him space, and call me. Some things are easier to talk through on the phone.

How I Approach It

The true answer is, it depends. I don't believe in a standard protocol, because no two dogs or families are the same. Each client is treated individually.

What I usually do is simple: I start with training the basics, then we increase the difficulty. That follows my four stages of training: Manage. Teach. Enforce. Enjoy. (The Four Stages of Training)

The basics that change walks the most:

  • His name. He looks at you when you say it, even with a little going on.
  • "Let's go." You change direction and he comes with you.
  • Sit for manners, down for calmness. At the door, at the curb, at home.
  • A loose leash. Pulling doesn't get him anywhere.
  • Rules at home. A dog who has structure in the house brings it out on the walk.

We practice those at home and in the driveway first, where it's easy. Then down the street. Then around a calm dog at a distance. Then a little closer. Set the dog up to succeed. If you teach a dog what to do, there is almost nothing left to correct. (The Dog Commandments)

And don't be surprised if your dog listens perfectly for me and struggles with you at first. That's normal. You're learning, too. (The Hardest Part of Dog Training Isn't the Dog)

What You Can Do This Week

(For more first steps on walks, read My Dog Barks and Lunges at Other Dogs: What Should I Do First?)

Related Reading

Not Sure What You've Got?

That's exactly what the free call is for. Tell me what happens on your walks and we'll figure out the best starting point together. Most of the families I see with "reactive" dogs start with The Six Essentials, because leash skills, calmness and clear rules are all part of it.

Learn more about Reactive Dog Training and private in-home dog training in West Palm Beach and Palm Beach County, Florida, or book your free call or call 561-884-2403.

When we learn, our dogs will listen.

Sources

Related topics: is my dog reactive | reactive dog training | dog barks at other dogs on walks | untrained dog vs reactive dog | reactive dog trainer West Palm Beach

Previous
Previous

My Dog Barks and Lunges at Other Dogs: What Should I Do First?

Next
Next

What Happens During Your First Private Dog Training Session?